DIY woodworking projects for every budget and skill level

TheCraftyCatsman: Main logo

xTool P2s Vs xTool F1. Which Machine Is Best for You?

xTool P2s vs xTool F1 Laser

Introduction

xTool P2S vs. xTool F1: Which Laser Engraver Is Right for You?

xTool P2S vs. xTool F1: Which Laser Engraver Fits Your Needs?

Whether you’re a small business owner, a DIY enthusiast, or a seasoned laser engraving pro, choosing the right machine can dramatically impact your workflow. Two standout options from xTool are the P2S CO₂ laser—a high-powered cutter and engraver—and the F1, a compact dual-laser system (diode + fiber) designed for versatile, on-the-go engraving. If you’re torn between fast, deep cuts on wood and acrylic or precise metal marking in a portable form factor, this comparison will help you weigh the pros and cons of each.

In this series, we’ll explore the key differences—from laser power and work area to material compatibility and pricing. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of whether the xTool P2S or the xTool F1 is your ideal pick for projects ranging from woodcraft and acrylic signs to metal tumblers and jewelry.

p2svsf1

xTool P2s vs xTool F1 Laser

Machine Overview

2. Detailed Machine Overviews

xTool P2S: CO₂ Power for Larger Projects

The xTool P2S is a 55W CO₂ laser engraver and cutter known for its ability to handle thicker materials like plywood, acrylic, leather, and even some rubber or foam products. Its enclosed design and built-in ventilation options make it ideal for small businesses or hobbyists working with medium-to-large projects. With a spacious bed (around 23.93 × 15.16 inches), you can create custom signs, intricate cutouts, and detailed engravings without frequent repositioning.

A standout feature is its AI-assisted camera alignment, part of xTool’s Creative Space software. This camera allows you to visually position your designs on the material, reducing trial-and-error. The P2S’s higher wattage also means faster cutting speeds and the capacity to tackle thicker stock than most diode lasers. It is a compelling solution for those who regularly produce wooden décor, acrylic signage, or leather goods and need consistent, professional results.

If you are still deciding between the P2 and P2S, check out our detailed comparison guide to see which model fits your needs best.

xTool F1: Compact Dual-Laser Versatility

The xTool F1 takes a different approach, blending a 10W diode laser with a 2W infrared fiber laser in a single, portable device. Its small footprint and open-frame design make it highly versatile for on-the-go engraving or use in tighter workspaces. While its working area is significantly smaller than the P2S (around 4.33 × 4.33 inches), the F1 excels at metal marking, jewelry engraving, and small craft projects that demand a dual-laser setup.

With the diode laser head, you can still work on wood, leather, and lightweight materials. But the real game-changer is the fiber laser head, allowing you to engrave logos, text, or patterns on metal with remarkable clarity. This makes the F1 a top choice for customizing metal tumblers, kitchen tools, or promotional items where portability and metal-friendly marking are top priorities. If you are looking for a multi-functional laser engraver that does not take up much room and handles a range of materials (including some metals), the xTool F1 offers a unique blend of flexibility and portability.

xTool P2s vs xTool F1 Laser

Comparison

3. Head-to-Head Comparison

Now that you know the basics of each machine, let’s see how they stack up side by side. Below, we break down the xTool P2S and xTool F1 across critical factors—laser power, material compatibility, cutting speed, and more—so you can quickly decide which engraver fits your projects.

    
Feature xTool P2S CO2 Laser Engraver
xTool P2S
CO₂ Laser Engraver
xTool F1 Fiber & Diode Laser
xTool F1
Dual-Laser (Diode + Fiber)
Laser Type & Power 55W CO₂ Laser
Ideal for wood & acrylic
10W Diode Laser + 2W Fiber Laser
Great for metal marking & small crafts
Working Area Approx. 23.93 × 15.16 in
(608 × 385 mm)
Spacious bed
Approx. 4.33 × 4.33 in
(110 × 110 mm)
Compact setup
Material Compatibility - Wood, plywood, MDF
- Acrylic, leather, paper
- Marking on coated metals & glass
Excellent for thicker cuts
- Wood, cardboard, light acrylic (diode)
- Metal & plastic marking (fiber)
Not suited for thick cutting
Cutting Speed & Depth Faster & deeper cuts on non-metal materials
Up to ~10 mm in wood (material-dependent)
Shallow cuts with diode head
Fiber laser focuses on surface marking for metals
Machine Footprint & Design Larger, enclosed body
Dedicated workspace recommended
Built-in exhaust/ventilation system
Small, open-frame
Highly portable, can be moved easily
Use caution with laser safety (open design)
Price Range $3,500–$5,500
(Varies by region & bundles)
Check Price
$999–$1,299
(Approx., check promotions)
Check Price
Check the Current Price Here

xTool P2s vs xTool F1 Laser

Use Cases

4. Real-World Use Cases

Beyond the specs and features, what really matters is how these machines fit into your day-to-day projects. Below are some common scenarios where the xTool P2S or the xTool F1 might shine. Think about the materials, workflows, and scale of your creative or commercial endeavors when deciding between these two devices.

Wood & Acrylic Crafts: Larger Signs, 3D Layering, and Deep Cuts

If you frequently produce wooden décor—such as laser-cut signs, mandalas, or layered wall art—the P2S offers the bed size and cutting power you need. Its 55W CO₂ laser effortlessly slices through ¼-inch or even ½-inch plywood (with multiple passes), making it a top pick for 3D layer assemblies or furniture prototypes. Similarly, thick acrylic signs or complex inlays benefit from the P2S’s fast, clean cuts.

In contrast, the F1’s diode laser can handle thinner wood or acrylic, but its smaller work area (~4.33" × 4.33") may limit you to smaller crafts—like custom keychains, ornament designs, or coasters. You can still achieve precise detail, but large-format tasks may become tedious unless you tile or reposition the material multiple times.

Metal Marking & Personalized Gifts

For those focused on engraving metal tumblers, flasks, knives, or jewelry, the xTool F1 stands out. Its fiber laser is specifically tuned to mark metals quickly and cleanly, producing crisp, permanent designs without any coating necessary. This makes it ideal for small businesses offering personalized metal gifts or promotional items. Its portability also means you could bring the F1 to events, fairs, or pop-up shops for on-the-spot engraving.

While the P2S can mark coated metals using certain spray treatments or anodized surfaces, its CO₂ laser doesn’t penetrate metal as effectively as a fiber laser. If your workflow revolves heavily around metal customization, the F1 has a clear advantage in speed, simplicity, and marking quality.

Portability & On-the-Go Crafting

One of the xTool F1’s unique selling points is its compact size and open-frame design. Hobbyists or freelancers who move between makerspaces or craft fairs will appreciate how lightweight and transportable the F1 can be. You can set up a quick engraving station almost anywhere—just be mindful of laser safety when operating in public or shared spaces.

The P2S, on the other hand, is larger and enclosed—much better suited for a dedicated workshop or small business where you keep the machine in one spot. It excels at long cutting sessions and thicker materials but is not easy to move around.

Production Runs & Business-Grade Throughput

If you’re regularly fulfilling bulk orders—like a small business laser-engraving wood signs, acrylic plaques, or custom boxes—the P2S stands out for its speed, power, and spacious bed. You can set up multiple pieces in one pass, reducing downtime and increasing profit margins.

Conversely, if your production niche is mostly metal gadgets, tumblers, or small promotional items, you might prefer the F1’s fiber laser. Even though the bed is smaller, metal marking is significantly faster and higher-quality on a dedicated fiber setup, compared to using coatings or lower-powered diode lasers on the market.

X-Carve CNC vs. xTool P2 Laser

FAQ

5. Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which machine is better for beginners?

If you're new to laser engraving, the xTool F1 is the easiest to start with. Its diode and fiber laser setup means no complicated ventilation is needed, and its compact size makes it plug-and-play. The xTool P2S is still beginner-friendly, but due to its larger footprint, CO₂ laser power, and fume extraction needs, it may require a more dedicated workspace and slightly more learning.

2. Can the xTool F1 cut through wood or acrylic?

The F1's diode laser can engrave and cut thin wood or acrylic, but it’s not as powerful as the P2S’s 55W CO₂ laser. Expect shallow cuts at slower speeds with the F1, whereas the P2S can cut through ¼-inch wood or acrylic in a single pass.

3. Can the xTool P2S engrave metal?

The P2S is a CO₂ laser, meaning it cannot engrave raw metals without additional treatment (such as coating sprays). If your focus is engraving stainless steel, aluminum, or jewelry, the xTool F1’s fiber laser is the better option.

4. Do I need special ventilation for the xTool P2S?

Yes. The P2S is a CO₂ laser, meaning it generates fumes and smoke when cutting materials like wood or acrylic. You’ll need proper ventilation or an air filtration system. The F1, on the other hand, produces far less smoke and does not require the same level of ventilation.

5. How fast is the xTool F1 compared to the P2S?

The F1's fiber laser is extremely fast for metal marking, often completing jobs in seconds. However, for cutting thicker materials, the P2S is much faster due to its higher laser wattage and power.

6. Which machine is better for businesses?

It depends on the type of business:

  • P2S: Best for businesses making wood signs, acrylic signage, custom cutting boards, and bulk laser cutting projects.
  • F1: Ideal for custom metal engraving, jewelry marking, and small personalized gift businesses.

7. Can I use third-party software like LightBurn?

Yes! Both the xTool P2S and xTool F1 support LightBurn, a popular laser engraving software, giving you more control over your designs.

8. Which machine is quieter?

The F1 is quieter since it uses diode and fiber lasers, which don’t require high-powered fans. The P2S, however, has internal cooling systems, air assist, and exhaust fans that make it louder.

9. Can the xTool F1 handle high-volume production?

The F1 is designed for quick, small-scale production, making it ideal for batch engraving metal gifts, jewelry, or tumblers. However, for high-volume wood or acrylic production, the P2S is the better choice due to its larger bed size and CO₂ cutting power.

Affiliate Links and Trusting Online Reviews:

It’s important to be cautious when reading online reviews, as many of them contain affiliate links that may influence the reviewer’s opinions. Often, reviewers can earn a commission for each product purchased through their links, which may lead to biased reviews or recommendations. In fact, tens of thousands of reviews on amazon are paid for. Sellers provide customers with reimbursements through paypal in order to avoid amazon detecting the fraud. We know all about this. Once upon a time this CraftyCat was in the top 10 of all amazon reviewers globally, I did this by abiding a code of ethics and writing fair and critical reviews of everything that I purchased. Once Amazon changed the rules and paypal payments became popular I decided to exit the hobby. Never once accepting a paypal payment for a “unbiased review”. Be an educated consumer and realize that virtually everything on the internet is for profit in one way or another. If nothing else then to support the content that is being created. That’s what affiliate links like the above do for this website. We love our speakeasy bar arcade, hidden bookcase door and virtual pinball machine but the truth is that they don’t contain any real affiliate links to generate revenue. Our in depth product reviews help support the build plans and other cools things that we offer  on the rest of our site. In fact, that’s why there aren’t many – our primary goal is to offer valuable, trustworthy information to our readers. Our commitment to quality ensures that you receive unbiased, well-researched insights to help you make informed decisions about the products you choose.

Not sure which laser cutter is right for you?

xTool vs OMTech vs Glowforge vs Gweike

Check out our comprehensive comparison of all top CO₂ laser cutters to find the perfect match for your needs and budget.

Side-by-side specs comparison
Materials capability charts
Real hands-on experience
2025 updated pricing & features
View Full Comparison Guide
xTool P2S
OMTech Polar+
Glowforge Pro
Gweike Cloud

How to Plan and Build a Bar in a Basement

Let’s Build a Bar!

Spalted Maple Bar Finished

Click above to get started on building your dream basement bar.