DIY woodworking projects for every budget and skill level

TheCraftyCatsman: Main logo

Carvera Air CNC Machine: Compact Precision – Is It Worth It for Hobbyists and Professionals?

 

Is the Carvera Air the Best Desktop CNC for Makers?

Is the Carvera Air the Best Desktop CNC for Makers?

The Carvera Air combines a compact form with powerful CNC capabilities, presenting an exciting option for hobbyists and professionals alike. CNC machines are typically big, messy, and loud, but can this desktop-sized system deliver on its promises?

As someone who has been laser engraving for almost 10 years, I’m constantly seeking tools to expand my creative possibilities. I’ve been a long-time fan of the xTool P2, and the Carvera Air offers the chance to add precision machining to my workflow.

In this article, we’ll dive into the Carvera Air’s features, compare it to the Nomad 3, and determine if it’s the best desktop CNC machine for creative makers and hobbyists.

Carvera Air

Introduction

Carvera Air CNC Machine - Compact and Versatile Desktop CNC

Carvera Air: Goldilocks on Price and Performance?

What Made Me Consider the Carvera Air?

When I first came across the original Carvera, I was immediately intrigued by its advanced features, such as the automatic tool changer, larger workspace, and integrated vacuum system. However, the steep price of over $5,000 made me hesitant—it felt like too big of a risk for a tool I wasn’t certain would pay off in my workflow.

The introduction of the Carvera Air, with a significantly lower price point, changed the game for me. While it sacrifices some premium features, it delivers on the core capabilities I’ve always wanted in a CNC machine, making it a much more appealing choice.

Pros and Cons of the Carvera Air

Below are the key pros and cons I considered when deciding whether the Carvera Air was worth the investment.

  • Pros:
    • Affordable price compared to the original Carvera.
    • Compact and fully enclosed design minimizes mess and noise.
    • Supports a variety of materials, including wood, plastics, aluminum, and even steel (with limitations).
    • Optional 4th-axis machining adds versatility for complex projects.
    • Includes support for popular CAM software like Fusion 360 and VCarve, as well as the upcoming MakeraCAM.
  • Cons:
    • Smaller bed size (11.8in x 7.9in x 5.1in) may limit certain projects.
    • No automatic tool changer—relies on a quick manual tool changer.
    • External dust collection system required for optimal use.
    • Still a significant investment, even at a lower price point.

Is the Carvera Air Worth It?

Ultimately, the Carvera Air delivers on everything I would want in a compact CNC machine at a more appealing price point. While the small bed size remains a concern, I believe it has the potential to enhance my workflow and open up new creative possibilities.

One exciting project I’d love to tackle with the Carvera Air is machining custom parts for my virtual pinball machine. Having a CNC machine like this could streamline the process of crafting precise brackets, panels, or decorative features like game themed toppers. Working in conjunction with my xTool P2 Laser, the personal use value is there but I need to make this work professionally. Stay tuned to see how that works out for me. 

Below is a detailed comparison between the Carvera and the Carvera Air to help you make an informed decision.

Carvera vs. Carvera Air Comparison

Carvera vs. Carvera Air - Specifications Comparison

Comparison of Carvera and Carvera Air
Feature
Carvera CNC Machine - Premium CNC with Advanced Features
Carvera
Carvera Air CNC Machine - Compact and Versatile Desktop CNC
Carvera Air
Price $5,199 (Standard) $2,099 (Standard)
Frame Type Aluminum frame with linear rails Die-cast aluminum frame with linear rods
Tool Changing System Automatic Tool Changer (ATC) with 6-tool capacity Quick Tool Changer (manual)
Spindle Power 200W, 0-15,000 RPM with closed-loop control 200W, 0-15,000 RPM with closed-loop control
Supported Collet Sizes ⅛" (integrated), optional: ¼", 6mm, 4mm ⅛" (integrated), optional: ¼", 6mm, 4mm
Working Area (X, Y, Z) 14.2in x 9.4in x 5.5in 12.6in x 8.7in x 4.7in
Axes 4-axis (X, Y, Z, optional A-axis) 4-axis (X, Y, Z, optional A-axis)
Software Includes Makera Controller and supports mainstream CAM software Includes Makera Controller and supports mainstream CAM software
Dust Collection Built-in vacuum system Dust shoe and vacuum port for external vacuum connection
Enclosure Fully enclosed for noise and dust control Fully enclosed for noise and dust control
Noise Level Approximately 50 dB (machine only) Approximately 50 dB (machine only)

For more details, visit the official websites: Carvera and Carvera Air

Carvera Air vs. Nomad 3: Which CNC is Right for You?

How Does the Carvera Air Compare to the Nomad 3?

As I explored the market for a desktop CNC machine, the Carvera Air and Nomad 3 stood out as strong contenders. Both machines offer compact designs, full enclosures, and reliable performance for a variety of materials. However, the Carvera Air's larger workspace, optional 4th-axis capability, and quick tool changer give it a versatility edge, while the Nomad 3 remains a solid choice for those prioritizing simplicity and proven reliability.

After carefully evaluating their features, strengths, and price points, I created a detailed comparison chart to highlight the differences between these two popular machines. This chart, located below, provides a clear side-by-side view to help you decide which CNC is the best fit for your needs.

Carvera Air

Let’s get down to business

Carvera Air vs Nomad 3: Comprehensive Feature Comparison

Carvera Air vs Nomad 3
Feature
Carvera Air CNC Machine - Compact and Versatile Desktop CNC
Carvera Air
Nomad 3 CNC Machine - Reliable and Compact CNC for Hobbyists
Nomad 3
Working Area 11.8in x 7.9in x 5.1in 8in x 8in x 3in
Tool Changer Quick Tool Changer Manual
Spindle Power 200W 130W
Materials Wood, Plastics, Aluminum, Brass, Steel (limited) Wood, Plastics, Aluminum, Brass
4th Axis Support Yes (Optional) No
Software Compatibility Fusion 360, VCarve, MakeraCAM Fusion 360, Carbide Create
Enclosure Fully Enclosed Fully Enclosed
 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Carvera Air CNC Machine?

The Carvera Air is a compact and versatile CNC machine designed for hobbyists and professionals alike. It features a quick tool changer, smaller bed size than the original Carvera, and optional add-ons like a laser module. Ideal for machining wood, plastics, and soft metals such as aluminum, it combines ease of use with powerful functionality.

What is the cutting capacity of the Carvera Air CNC Machine?

The Carvera Air offers a cutting capacity of 11.8in x 7.9in x 5.1in (300mm x 200mm x 130mm) for 3-axis machining. For 4-axis machining, it supports materials up to 3.6in in diameter and 7.9in in length (92mm x 200mm). This bed size makes it ideal for small to medium projects.

How does the Carvera Air compare to the Nomad 3?

The Carvera Air outshines the Nomad 3 in several areas, including a larger workspace (11.8in x 7.9in x 5.1in vs. 8in x 8in x 3in), an optional 4th-axis for advanced machining, and a quick tool changer. While the Nomad 3 is known for its reliability, the Carvera Air's versatility makes it a strong choice for intricate projects.

What materials can the Carvera Air machine?

The Carvera Air can handle a variety of materials, including wood, plastics, aluminum, and brass. It is also capable of machining steel at slower feed rates but is optimized for softer materials.

What CAM software is compatible with the Carvera Air?

The Carvera Air supports popular CAM software like Fusion 360 and VCarve. Additionally, MakeraCAM, a proprietary software, supports 2D, 3D relief, laser, and PCB projects, making it an excellent choice for diverse machining needs.

What type of milling bits does the Carvera Air support?

The Carvera Air comes with a 1/8-inch collet and includes free milling bits. It also supports 1/4-inch, 6mm, and 4mm bits with optional collets, offering exceptional versatility for different project requirements.

What are the power requirements for the Carvera Air?

The Carvera Air operates on 100-120VAC or 200-240VAC @ 50/60Hz with a maximum input power of 400 watts.

  

Carvera Air

Conclusion

Conclusion: Why I Chose the Carvera Air

Why Did I Choose the Carvera Air?

After carefully weighing the pros and cons, comparing it to the Nomad 3, and considering my creative needs, I decided to order the Carvera Air. Its larger workspace, quick tool changer, and optional 4th-axis capabilities make it an excellent choice for hobbyists like me. At its price point, it strikes a balance between functionality and affordability, making it a compelling addition to my workflow.

As a hobbyist, the Carvera Air fits my needs perfectly. For professionals or makers needing to cut large sheets of plywood, a CNC with a larger bed capacity might be more suitable. For instance, MakerMade offers products like their MakerMade M2 CNC, which is designed for cutting larger materials. However, I don't think the Carvera Air and MakerMade's offerings are directly comparable—they serve different niches.

While the smaller bed size and manual tool changes were initial concerns, the Carvera Air's versatility and potential to expand my creative projects outweighed these drawbacks. I’m especially excited to see how it will streamline projects like machining parts for my virtual pinball machine.

Stay tuned as I update this page with my hands-on experience and findings after receiving the Carvera Air. I look forward to sharing whether this compact CNC machine truly lives up to its promises and how it enhances my creative workflow.

Affiliate Links and Trusting Online Reviews:

It’s important to be cautious when reading online reviews, as many of them contain affiliate links that may influence the reviewer’s opinions. Often, reviewers can earn a commission for each product purchased through their links, which may lead to biased reviews or recommendations. In fact, tens of thousands of reviews on amazon are paid for. Sellers provide customers with reimbursements through paypal in order to avoid amazon detecting the fraud. We know all about this. Once upon a time this CraftyCat was in the top 10 of all amazon reviewers globally, I did this by abiding a code of ethics and writing fair and critical reviews of everything that I purchased. Once Amazon changed the rules and paypal payments became popular I decided to exit the hobby. Never once accepting a paypal payment for a “unbiased review”. Be an educated consumer and realize that virtually everything on the internet is for profit in one way or another. If nothing else then to support the content that is being created. That’s what affiliate links like the above do for this website. We love our speakeasy bar arcade, hidden bookcase door and virtual pinball machine but the truth is that they don’t contain any real affiliate links to generate revenue. Our in depth product reviews help support the build plans and other cools things that we offer  on the rest of our site. In fact, that’s why there aren’t many – our primary goal is to offer valuable, trustworthy information to our readers. Our commitment to quality ensures that you receive unbiased, well-researched insights to help you make informed decisions about the products you choose.

How to Plan and Build a Bar in a Basement

Let’s Build a Bar!

Spalted Maple Bar Finished

Click above to get started on building your dream basement bar.